Rejected entry feedback system spec¶
{
"paths": [
"packages/core/src/DateInput/useTypedDate.ts",
"packages/core/src/Field/useEntryErrorReport.ts",
"packages/core/src/Field/useValueReplacesEntry.ts",
"packages/core/src/DateInput/DateInput.tsx",
"packages/core/src/DateInput/NativeDateField.tsx",
"packages/core/src/DateTimeInput/**",
"packages/core/src/TimeInput/**",
"packages/core/src/NumberInput/**"
]
}
Intent¶
When an input that checks its own entries refuses an entry, the person learns
it once, in words they hear and, in a standalone field, see, and keeps what
they typed so they can correct it. An entry the person has not finished is
never flagged, so a lone - never flashes an error. Apps change no code: the
committed value, onChange, and what a form posts keep working as they do.
Members¶
The rule applies to four members of family:input-fields that reject typed or
reported entries themselves: DateInput, DateTimeInput, TimeInput, and
NumberInput. FileInput also rejects entries, a file of the wrong type or
size, and drops them from its value; those are picked files, not typed or
reported entries, so it is outside this record. Members that reject nothing
themselves, such as TextInput, Selector, and DateRangeInput, are outside
it too.
Non-goals¶
- A builder's choice to hold a member's rejections until commit for a form or a
field, which
spec:AST-117owns asentryErrorBehavior. - Where a member inside an InputGroup shows status.
component:InputGroupFR1,component:TextInputFR1, andcomponent:TimeInputFR10 own it; FR5 states how a grouped rejection is announced. - Caller validation. A caller's
status,isRequired, and form-library rules keep their meaning; FR7 states which message shows when a caller status and a rejection meet. - Native constraint validation in the browser, such as
requiredand:invalid. - Rejection wording. Each member's record and
spec:AST-111AR3 own the messages;spec:AST-086owns their delivery. - What a commit does with an entry the member accepts: commit, clamp, or clear stays with each member's record.
- The
onChangetiming of typed entry, which each member's record owns (spec:AST-111FR12 for dates). - Equivalent internal implementations remain valid when they satisfy this contract.
- Internal modules, files, function names, algorithms, data structures, storage layouts, manifests, journals, locks, transaction protocols, and CI job/workflow topology belong in architecture or implementation unless callers or interoperating systems intentionally depend on that exact mechanism as a public protocol. In that case, state who depends on it and why an equivalent implementation would not satisfy the contract.
Public contract¶
interface NumberInputEntryError {
kind: 'unreadable' | 'fractional' | 'outOfRange';
text: string; // the typed text
value?: number; // the number the text names, for 'fractional' and 'outOfRange'
}
interface TimeInputEntryError {
kind: 'unreadable' | 'outOfRange';
text: string; // the typed text
value?: ISOTimeString; // the time the text names, for 'outOfRange'
}
<NumberInput
label="Seats"
value={seats}
onChange={setSeats}
isIntegerOnly
min={1}
max={40}
onEntryErrorChange={setSeatsEntryError} // optional
status={
seatsEntryError?.kind === 'fractional'
? {type: 'error', message: 'Enter a whole number of seats'}
: undefined
}
/>
Requirements¶
Terms¶
- A value rejection refuses an entry that reads as a value the member does
not accept: a date the calendar does not have; a date, time, or date-time
outside
min,max, ordateConstraints; a number outsideminormax. - A text rejection refuses an entry that does not read as a value: unreadable or incomplete date text, time text that does not parse, number text that does not parse, and a fractional number in an integer-only field.
- A commit is Enter in the field or blur, focus leaving the field.
- An entry is complete when FR1 says so.
- A standalone field is a member that is not inside an InputGroup.
Behavior¶
- FR1 — Each kind of entry has its own point of completion. Typed, pasted,
and dropped text are judged alike. Under
entryErrorBehavior="complete", a member reveals its rejections at these points, and under'blur-or-enter'at commit (spec:AST-117FR3, FR4).- A typed date is complete as
spec:AST-111FR12 defines it: every field is present, the year is complete or is an era year with its era, no separator trails, and the last field cannot take another digit. Gregorian text that only the fallback reader reads (spec:AST-111FR9) is complete only at commit. - A typed time is complete when its hours, both minute digits, and, when the field shows seconds, both second digits are present, and, in twelve-hour text, its day period, unless the hour reads as 0 or 13 through 23.
- A typed number has no fixed length, so it is complete only at commit.
While a person types,
NumberInputmarks, shows, and announces nothing, whatever the draft. At commit it reveals the draft's rejection: text that does not parse, a fraction in an integer-only field, or a number outside the range when no number can commit (minabovemax); a number outside an ordinary range clamps and commits (component:NumberInputFR3) and reveals none. A number's rejection therefore appears at commit under eitherentryErrorBehaviorvalue. - A value that a native date control reports is complete only at commit:
while a person types its year, the control reports each partial year as a
date, such as
0002-05-10. - A value that a native time control reports is complete when the control reports it.
- A typed date is complete as
- FR2 — A value rejection appears once the entry is complete. A member reveals a value rejection as soon as the entry is complete, while focus stays in the field. An entry that is committed before it is complete reveals its rejection at commit.
- FR3 — A text rejection waits for commit. Text that does not read as a value is never complete. While a person types, the member neither marks it invalid nor announces it; its rejection appears at commit.
- FR4 — Commit keeps rejected text, and never discards an entry silently.
Enter or blur on typed text with a rejection keeps the text in the field and
shows the rejection. The committed value does not change, and
onChangedoes not fire. What a form posts does not change. After a blur that keeps a rejectedNumberInputorTimeInputdraft, and after Enter or blur on unreadableDateInputorDateTimeInputdate text, a hidden input carries the caller'snamewith the committed value's text, and the typed input carries none: forNumberInput, the committed number as the field shows it on the latest stable release, the plain number (2.5) while the field is not focused and the plain locale-formatted number (2,5inde-DE) while it is (component:NumberInputFR6); and the committed value as the field shows it forTimeInput,DateInput, andDateTimeInput's date segment (component:TimeInputFR11,component:DateInputFR25,component:DateTimeInputFR8). In every other case the input that carriesnameon the latest stable release keeps it, and a form posts what it posts there: the typed text of aNumberInputwithoutformatValueor aTimeInputdraft that Enter submits before blur, and incomplete date text or a date the calendar does not have or thatmin,max, ordateConstraintsrules out. ANumberInputwithformatValueposts the committed number from its hidden input in every case, as it does there. The hidden input carriesnameuntil the person edits the kept text, or a newvalueor a pick replaces it; the typed input then carriesnameagain. Avaluethat the caller passes in the same update as an Enter or blur that keeps rejected text, as a caller that restores its own value at that commit does, does not replace the kept text: the text, its rejection, and its message stay, and a later newvaluereplaces it (DEC-14). Unreadable date text that Enter or blur kept is not pending typed text forcomponent:DateInputFR16 andcomponent:DateTimeInputFR10: the next Enter with no edit submits a surrounding form, and the hidden input posts the committed date. No member reverts rejected text. A native date or time control restores the committed value at blur, because its own value is what a form posts: a form that Enter submits before blur posts the value the control holds. Its rejection stays revealed, with every signal FR5 gives it, as FR6 states, so the restore is never silent. An empty entry is not a rejection: a commit clears it or restores the committed value, as each member's record states.NumberInputclamps a number outside its range at commit (component:NumberInputFR3), so that rejection ends at the commit. - FR5 — A rejection is a visible message, and its signals move together. In
a standalone field, a rejection that appears shows its message as the field's
error status, in the field's status placement and tied to the control by
aria-describedby, except where FR7 shows a caller status in its place; setsaria-invalid="true"on the control; and is announced once (spec:AST-086FR1, FR6, FR7). Any invalid styling of the entry's text appears with them. None of these appears before the others, and none stays after the others clear. Inside an InputGroup, a member shows no status of its own and the group shows only its ownstatus, as the InputGroup, TextInput, and TimeInput records state; there the rejection setsaria-invalidand is announced once through the field's alert. A shown status announces itself, and the field's alert carries only a message that no shown status announces: inside an InputGroup, and where FR7 shows a caller status in place of the field's message. When both segments of aDateTimeInputhold a rejection, the field's status shows the date segment's message, which comes first; the time segment's rejection setsaria-invalidon its input and is announced once through the field's alert. - FR6 — A shown rejection clears as soon as the entry is valid. An edit
that makes the entry a value the member accepts, or empties it, clears the
rejection at once, without a commit. An edit that leaves the entry rejected
or incomplete keeps the shown rejection and does not announce it again. The
next commit, or the next complete entry, replaces it with the entry's current
rejection: a changed message, as when one complete wrong entry is edited into
another, is announced once, and the same message is not announced again. A
new
valuefrom the caller, or a date or time the member accepts picked from a Calendar, sheet, or native picker, replaces the entry and clears its rejection, except avaluethat the caller passes in the same update as an Enter or blur that keeps the entry or its rejection, which leaves the entry and its rejection in place (FR4, DEC-14). - FR7 — A caller status never hides a rejection behind a warning. A
warningorsuccesscaller status never replaces a rejection's message, on any member, with or withoutonEntryErrorChange, and a callererrorstatus without a message keeps the field's message. A callererrorstatus with a message shows in place of the field's message onNumberInput,TimeInput, andDateTimeInput's time segment, with or without the callback. OnDateInputandDateTimeInput's date segment, it shows in place of the field's message only withonEntryErrorChange; without the callback, the field's message shows in place of any callerstatuswhile the rejected text stays, as their records state. While a callererrorstatus shows in place of the field's message,aria-invalidstays set while the rejection stands. Without the callback, the field's alert announces the rejection's own message once; with it, the caller's message is the one announced, and a rejection that starts under an unchanged caller error message changes no status, so the field's alert announces that message once. - FR8 —
NumberInputandTimeInputreport their rejections. Each takes an optionalonEntryErrorChange, which receives aNumberInputEntryErroror aTimeInputEntryErroreach time the rejection the field reveals changes, andnullwhen it ends.kindisunreadablefor text that is not a number or a time,fractionalfor a fraction in an integer-onlyNumberInput, andoutOfRangefor a time outsideminormax, or a number whenminis abovemax(FR1);textis the typed text;valueis the number or ISO time the text names, forfractionalandoutOfRange. Typing, Enter, blur, a newvalue,min,max, orisIntegerOnly, and disabling, which hides the rejection, each report a changed rejection; avaluethat the caller passes in the same update as an Enter or blur that keeps a rejection changes no rejection, so it reports nothing, notnull(FR4, DEC-14); an unchanged rejection never reports again; a field that unmounts while a reported rejection stands reportsnull.TimeInput's native and sheet surfaces take no typed text, so they never report. - FR9 — Enter commits every typed field. Enter in the typed field of each
member is a commit, so it reveals a text rejection there. In
TimeInputandDateTimeInput's time segment it is not prevented beyond that commit, so a surrounding form submits as it does from any text field: a valid draft has already committed while it was typed, and a rejected draft changes no value. While the time segment's preset-time list is open, Enter picks the typed or highlighted time from it and does not submit. - FR10 — Disabled and busy fields reveal no rejection. While a member is
disabled or busy, it reveals no rejection of its own, as its record states
(
spec:AST-085FR2), and reportsnull(FR8). A member that keeps typed text through a lock, asDateInputandDateTimeInput's date segment do (component:DateInputFR12), reveals and reports that text's rejection again once it is editable.NumberInputandTimeInputdrop a draft when they become disabled (component:NumberInputFR9,component:TimeInputFR9), so no rejection returns.
Accessibility contract¶
- AR1 — No false alarms. An unfinished entry produces no announcement and no invalid state (FR1–FR3).
- AR2 — One announcement per rejection. Each rejection that appears is
announced once, at the urgency
spec:AST-086FR5 gives an error (FR5, FR7). - AR3 — Not by color alone. In a standalone field, a rejection is a visible
message tied to the control by
aria-describedby, never only a text color (WCAG 2.2 1.4.1, 3.3.1). Where FR7 shows a callererrorstatus in its place, that status is the visible message, and the rejection is announced and setsaria-invalid. Inside an InputGroup, the rejection is announced and setsaria-invalid, and a visible message of the member's own is a gap the InputGroup records own. - AR4 — Nothing is discarded silently. A commit keeps rejected text with its message, and a native control that restores its committed value keeps the rejection revealed (FR4), so a person always learns that an entry was not accepted (WCAG 2.2 3.3.1).
Compatibility¶
Every change in this record applies with no prop set, and together they are one
accessibility behavior fix under spec:AST-017 FR53: their purpose is to make
DateInput, DateTimeInput, TimeInput, and NumberInput conform to WCAG 2.2
1.4.1 (Use of Color) and 3.3.1 (Error Identification), both Level A.
spec:AST-017 FR3 sends a change to documented interaction or accessibility
behavior made for accessibility conformance to FR53.
- The fix ships as a patch
[fix], with a release-note line, and its Changeset names the old and new behavior and the two success criteria. - It requires no app-layer code change. Existing props, types, exports, tokens,
and documented usage keep working; the committed value and
onChangedo not change; what a form posts does not change, because a hidden input carries the committed value's text wherever the latest stable release reverts rejected text, and elsewhere the input that carriesnameon the release keeps it (FR4); andNumberInput,TimeInput, andDateTimeInput's time segment keep a callererrorstatus with a message shown over their own message (FR7). onEntryErrorChangeand itsNumberInputEntryErrorandTimeInputEntryErrortypes are optional public surface that FR53 admits under the rules for public additions (spec:AST-017FR5). Nothing is removed, renamed, or narrowed.- Behavior it replaces, on the latest stable release:
- A rejected
NumberInputorTimeInputdraft shows only as secondary-color text, its message reaches only an assertive visually hidden region, and blur reverts it with no message.component:NumberInputAR2 relies on that hidden alert for WCAG 3.3.1. - Unreadable
DateInputandDateTimeInputdate text, and an out-of-range edit in a native date or time control, do the same; the native control restores its committed value at blur and drops the rejection. - Each of them also marks and announces an unfinished entry, such as a lone
-, on each keystroke.
- A rejected
- Behavior it ships, in all four members: in a standalone field, a visible
message tied to the field by
aria-describedby(FR5, FR7); rejected text kept in the field at commit and never reverted, and a native restore that keeps its rejection revealed (FR4); and no invalid state or alert while an entry is unfinished, with unreadable text revealed at commit (FR1–FR3).NumberInputreveals every rejection at commit and nothing while the person types. - Two submissions post rejected text, as they do on the latest stable release:
incomplete date text or a date the calendar does not have or that its bounds
rule out, which
DateInputandDateTimeInputkeep after blur, and aNumberInputwithoutformatValueor aTimeInputdraft that Enter submits before blur (FR4, DEC-13). - Two screens an app chose change, as part of the same fix:
- A
NumberInput,TimeInput, or time segment with a callerwarningorsuccessstatus shows the rejection's message in place of that status while a rejection stands, because a field marked invalid must say why (WCAG 2.2 3.3.1), asDateInputalready does (FR7). - Unreadable
DateInputandDateTimeInputdate text stays at commit, and its message replaces a callerstatuswhile it stays, following the shippedDateInputrule that the field's own message wins; on the latest stable release the text reverts and the caller's status stays shown (FR4, FR7).
- A
Platform support¶
- Supported feature/engine floor: every supported browser and renderer. Nothing here is behind a capability check.
- Unsupported behavior: none.
- Browser evidence: DOM and accessibility-tree assertions for the error status,
aria-invalid,aria-describedby, and live-region text at each keystroke and commit, standalone and inside an InputGroup, with and without a callerstatus; a real-browser check of the partial years a native date control reports while the year is typed, of the native restore at blur, and that blur and Enter commit on the typed surfaces, Enter inTimeInputand theDateTimeInputtime segment still submitting its form.
Current-state impact¶
family:input-fieldsadds FR15, a projection of this record.component:DateInputFR25,component:DateTimeInputFR16,component:TimeInputFR14 and FR15, andcomponent:NumberInputFR15 and FR16 project FR1–FR10, and the rows that describe a revert, a keystroke alert, or a rejection shown only by color point to them.component:NumberInputFR6,component:TimeInputFR11,component:DateInputFR25, andcomponent:DateTimeInputFR8 post the committed value's text from a hidden input after blur keeps a rejected draft, or Enter or blur keeps unreadable date text.component:DateTimeInputFR16 shows the date segment's message when both segments hold a rejection.component:NumberInputandcomponent:TimeInputaddonEntryErrorChangeand their entry-error types. Thespec:AST-117projections,component:NumberInputFR14,component:TimeInputFR13,component:DateInputFR24, andcomponent:DateTimeInputFR15, reveal rejections under'complete'when these projections state, and keep rejected text under'blur-or-enter'.- The
.doc.mjsfiles of the four components describe when a rejection shows, that rejected text stays at commit, and which message wins over a callerstatus; theNumberInputandTimeInputdocs describeonEntryErrorChange.
Requirement gaps, each a WCAG 2.2 Level A mismatch that FR53 fixes unless it says otherwise:
- AR3 gap (WCAG 2.2 3.3.1), outside this fix: inside an InputGroup, a member's
own rejection is announced and sets
aria-invalidbut shows no visible message.
Verification¶
| Contract | Verification | Representative states | Mutation or failure expectation |
|---|---|---|---|
| FR1 | Completeness unit cases per kind of entry | Dates per spec:AST-111 FR12; 1:3, 1:30, 1:30 PM, 13:30 in 12- and 24-hour fields; -, 1a, 150 with max={100} while typed and at commit; 0002-05-10 |
An unfinished entry counts as complete, or a complete one waits |
| FR2, FR3 | Keystroke-by-keystroke suites | Each value and text rejection of each member; native date year typing; pasted text | A rejection appears before the entry is complete, a text rejection appears while typing, or a complete value rejection waits |
| FR4 | Enter and blur suites; native form submission | Each rejection kind; empty entry; NumberInput past a bound; a kept NumberInput draft in a decimal-comma locale, posted focused and unfocused; a native restore; a form posted after Enter and after blur on each kept rejection |
Text reverts or commits, onChange fires, a form posts other than FR4 says, a native restore drops its rejection, or a clamp is reported |
| FR5, FR7 | Accessibility-tree and live-region assertions | Standalone, horizontal-labels; InputGroup (alert only); each status placement; no caller status; an error, warning, and success status; callback or none |
The signals appear or clear apart, a warning or success status hides a rejection, the wrong message wins, or an announcement repeats |
| FR6 | Edit suites after a shown rejection | Edit to valid; to empty; to incomplete; to another rejection; caller value change, and one at each commit that keeps the entry; calendar pick |
A fixed entry keeps its rejection, an incomplete edit clears it or announces it again, or a pick leaves it |
| FR8 | NumberInput and TimeInput callback suites |
Each kind; the rejection ending by typing, a new value, or a new bound; disabling; unmount; an unchanged rejection; native and sheet surfaces |
A report is missing, repeats an unchanged rejection, carries the wrong kind or value, or comes from a surface with no typed text |
| FR9 | Enter suites in a form | TimeInput and the DateTimeInput time segment with a rejected draft, a valid draft, and no draft; the preset-time list open |
Enter reveals nothing for a rejected draft, a closed time field prevents the form's submission, or Enter in the open list submits |
| FR10 | Disabled and busy suites | Rejection shown, then disabled; DateInput text kept while busy; a NumberInput draft when disabled |
A locked field reveals or reports a rejection, kept DateInput text loses its rejection once editable, or a dropped draft's rejection returns |
| AR1–AR4 | Screen-reader evidence under spec:AST-009 |
Each member, typed and native, standalone and grouped, with and without a caller status |
An unfinished entry is announced, a rejection is heard twice, or a commit discards an entry with no message |
Decision log¶
DEC-1 — An unfinished entry is never flagged¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-1
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
Form guidance advises against flagging an entry a person has not finished, and
allows checking a fixed-length entry once it is fully typed. A field marks and
announces nothing while an entry is unfinished, so a lone - never flashes an
error (FR1–FR3).
Rejected: a pause in typing as completion, because its timing differs between people and assistive technologies.
DEC-2 — A date or time completes when every field is present¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-2
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
Typed dates and times have a fixed set of fields, so they are complete when every field is present. A native date control reports partial years while its year is typed, so its value is complete only at commit (FR1). DEC-12 covers numbers.
DEC-3 — Text that is not a value waits for commit and then stays¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-3
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
Unreadable text is never complete, so it waits for commit. A commit that dropped it would discard the person's entry with no message, so the commit keeps it and shows why (FR3, FR4).
DEC-4 — Every rejection is a visible message¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-4
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
A rejection that is only announced, or only colors the text, leaves a sighted person without the reason and a screen-reader user with words no one else sees. In a standalone field, the field's error status carries the reason for everyone, and its announcement is the one announcement (FR5). DEC-10 covers a member inside an InputGroup.
DEC-5 — A caller error status keeps each member's precedence¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-5
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
NumberInput, TimeInput, and DateTimeInput's time segment show a caller
error status over their own message, and DateInput shows its message over
the caller's, as each does on the latest stable release. onEntryErrorChange
gives NumberInput and TimeInput the rejection, so an app that wants its own
wording passes it as an error status (FR7, FR8). DEC-8 names the two screens
that change.
DEC-6 — Enter commits TimeInput and still submits the form¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-6
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
Enter reveals a rejected draft's message, and the field does not prevent it
beyond that commit, so a form submits from TimeInput as it does from any text
field. A valid draft has already committed while it was typed, and a rejected
draft posts its typed text, as on the latest stable release (FR4, FR9). DateTimeInput's time segment follows the same rule
outside its preset-time list.
DEC-7 — A shown rejection stays until the entry is valid¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-7
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
A rejection clears the moment the entry is fixed, so a correction gets immediate credit. An edit that leaves the entry wrong does not make the rejection untrue, so the rejection stays without a new announcement. A changed message is new information, so it is announced once (FR6).
DEC-8 — These changes are one accessibility behavior fix¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-8
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
Each change makes the four members meet WCAG 2.2 1.4.1 and 3.3.1 in a
standalone field, and none needs an app to change code, so they ship together
as a patch under spec:AST-017 FR53. A caller error status keeps its place
on NumberInput and TimeInput (DEC-5), and what a form posts does not change
(DEC-13). Two screens an app chose change as part of
the fix: a warning or success status gives way to a rejection's message
(DEC-11), and unreadable DateInput text stays at commit with its message in
place of a caller status, as the field's message already wins there.
DEC-9 — A native control restores its value and keeps the rejection¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-9
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
A native date or time control's own value is what a form posts, so a refused
date or time cannot stay in it. The control restores the committed value at
blur and keeps the rejection's message, aria-invalid, and announcement, so
the restore says why (FR4).
DEC-10 — A grouped member announces its rejection¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-10
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
Inside an InputGroup, the group owns the only visible status, and its records
give a member no message box of its own. A grouped member's rejection is
announced and sets aria-invalid; a visible message there belongs to the
InputGroup records (FR5, AR3).
DEC-11 — A warning or success status never hides a rejection¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-11
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
A field marked invalid that reads "Looks good" names no error, against WCAG 2.2
3.3.1, so a warning or success caller status never replaces a rejection's
message on any member, with or without onEntryErrorChange, as DateInput
already does (FR7).
DEC-12 — A typed number is complete only at commit¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-12
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-11
A number has no fixed length, so no point before Enter or blur says it is
finished. NumberInput reveals a typed number's rejection at commit and
nothing while the person types, as React Aria's NumberField shows validation
when the person commits the value, typically on blur (FR1).
Rejected: a number that no digit typed at its end can bring into range counting as complete, because the test is complex and easy to get wrong with negative numbers and decimals.
DEC-13 — What a form posts does not change¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-13
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-12
A form posts what it posts on the latest stable release. Where that release
reverts rejected text at a commit, the member keeps the text, and a hidden
input carries the caller's name with the committed value's text, which the
release posts once the text reverts. Elsewhere, the input that carries name
on the release keeps it and posts what it posts there. No posted value changes, so the change
stays an accessibility behavior fix under spec:AST-017 FR53 (FR4).
Rejected: the committed value's text in every case, because it changes what a
released form posts, which spec:AST-017 FR1 classes as breaking.
DEC-14 — A value passed at a commit that keeps the entry keeps it¶
Reference: spec:AST-118/DEC-14
Decider: nynexman4464, 2026-11-12
A caller can pass a new value from an Enter or blur that keeps rejected
text, as a live filter does when it restores the value it had before the
edit. A field that took that value as a replacement would erase the text the
commit just kept and discard the entry with no message (FR4, AR4). Keeping an
invalid entry with a chance to correct it is preferred to removing it. A
value passed in the same update as any Enter or blur that keeps rejected
text, the first or a later one, therefore leaves the entry, its rejection, and
its message, and reports no change; a later new value replaces the entry
(FR4, FR6, FR8).
Rejected: sparing only the commit that reveals the rejection, because Enter and then a blur that restores the value would erase the text.
Open questions¶
None.
本页原文 Markdown:在 AtomGit 查看·内容源自开源项目 as/astryx